Legacy ATS: Overcoming Limitations and Transitioning Towards Modern Recruitment Tools

Sofia Lindman Future of HR

In the fast-paced world of recruitment, traditional Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) have long been relied upon to streamline the search for qualified candidates. However, as business needs evolve, these once reliable systems start showing their limitations. They struggle with modern needs, potentially slowing down the hiring process. Consequently, there's a growing shift towards newer, adaptable, and more efficient recruitment tools that can better handle today's complex hiring demands.

With continuous technological advancements, it's time to rethink your old systems, break free from outdated methods, and move towards modern recruitment tools. A shift doesn't just aim to fix problems associated with traditional ATS, it aims to transform the recruitment process, promoting a more agile, data-driven, and candidate-focused approach. While the path may seem challenging, the rewards are too significant to ignore. This transition isn't just a convenience anymore but an essential step to keep pace with the changing times. Isn't it time you fully embrace technology to enhance your recruitment strategies for the future? This article serves as your roadmap to navigate this essential shift successfully.

Blog image 88

Common Problems and Limitations of Legacy ATS

While your legacy ATS has dutifully served its purpose in the past, its disadvantages are becoming increasingly evident, which can create a bottleneck in your overall hiring process. Let's explore some of these major limitations in more detail:

  1. Limited functionalities. Legacy ATS often falls short in advanced functionalities, such as reporting and analytics, which are crucial for strategic decision-making in today's data-driven world.
  2. Inadequate integration capabilities. With the ongoing technological revolution in HR, integrating old systems with fresh tech can be an uphill battle, affecting the efficiency and effectiveness of your recruitment process.
  3. Poor candidate experience. Outdated ATS can complicate the application process, leading to a less-than-ideal experience for job seekers.
  4. Slow processing time. Given its design, old-school ATS can be sluggish and inefficient, slowing your time-to-hire and possibly allowing good candidates to slip through the cracks.
  5. Limited customization. Unlike modern solutions, legacy ATS often lack customization features, making it challenging to tailor the system to your organization's specific needs.
  6. Lack of mobile optimization.  As the world grows more mobile-centric, an ATS that doesn't play well with mobile devices can impede access and use for both recruiters and candidates.
  7. High maintenance needs. Frequent updates and fixes can often lead to extended downtime and escalating recruitment and operational costs.

Why You Need to Transition to Modern Recruitment Tools

In your quest of transforming your hiring process, modern recruitment tools offer various benefits that streamline your talent acquisition. The first step to winning the talent game lies in enhancing the candidate experience. Modern tools like Jobylon excel here, providing a smooth application process that leaves candidates with a positive first impression of your company. Additionally, these platforms boost your recruitment efficiency, expediting processes, removing roadblocks, and cutting down time-to-hire.

Advanced tools integrate seamlessly with new technologies, creating a well-knit recruitment ecosystem. They come armed with powerful analytics, offering crucial data for informed decision-making. The scalability ensures that your recruitment strategies keep pace as your business grows. What's more, these tools boost candidate engagement, strengthening your employer brand. Also, their high customizability lets you shape your recruitment process to match your unique needs. Transitioning to modern recruitment tools isn't about replacing the old but using the new to elevate your hiring game to new heights. After all, adapting to change is not just survival, it's progress.

Koenigsegg Automotive AB, well-known for their innovative sports cars, embarked on this transition to overcome their hiring hurdles. Their goal was to simplify the recruitment process and find a more efficient way to attract top-notch talent who thrive in fast-paced settings. The results were impressive: their time-to-hire dramatically dropped from a significant 2 months to an impressive 25 days. This change clearly demonstrates the impactful role that modern recruitment tools can play in driving transformation.

Key Steps to Transition Away from Legacy ATS

Moving away from familiar systems can indeed be intimidating, but transitioning from a legacy ATS to innovative recruitment tools can be a smooth process with a well-defined plan. To navigate this transition successfully, here are the essential steps you can follow:

1. Identify your specific needs 

Establishing a clear understanding of your unique recruitment needs is a pivotal starting point for the journey away from a legacy ATS. It's because this awareness uncovers the areas where your current system falls short, paving the way for you to pinpoint the specific functionalities you seek in a modern tool. This helps prevent the mistake of jumping from an old system to a new one without properly addressing existing issues. For example, if you're battling with poor candidate experiences, a modern solution enhancing the overall candidate journey becomes a priority. 

Don’t rush the process. Invest time engaging with key stakeholders and your recruitment team to gather insights about desired features, existing hurdles, and unmet needs. While doing so, consider your business growth plans, and how your new system should adapt to this. Examine your recruitment analytics and identify improvement areas. Additionally, take into account the candidate experience, as this can significantly influence your brand perception. This key step will allow you to ensure your new recruitment tool will not just be modern, but truly transformative for your hiring process.

2. Explore your options

The significance of exploring your options lies in the fact that no two recruitment solutions are the same - each comes with its unique mix of features, benefits, and even limitations. The goal isn't to find the best tool out there but to discover the one that fits your requirements. Remember, your identified needs serve as the compass here, ensuring you stay on track and don't get swayed by shiny features that might not add value to your unique recruitment process.

Now, how do we conduct this exploration? Start by shortlisting prospective vendors. Reviews, user testimonials, and case studies can shed light on the reliability and performance of these tools. Lean into industry forums and discussions to get a sense of user satisfaction. Additionally, take note of the platforms that offer industry-specific benefits, which can add a significant edge to your recruitment process. Lastly, but most importantly, avail the trial versions when possible. Nothing beats hands-on experience to understand if the tool truly delivers what it promises, right?

3. Conduct pilot testing 

Just like rehearsals before a big performance, it is important to conduct pilot testing before fully transitioning to a new recruitment tool. It serves as your safety net, catching any potential hitches or hiccups that might disrupt your hiring process down the line. Moreover, a pilot test allows you to assess the new tool's compatibility with your recruitment needs, giving you the confidence to make an informed transition decision. It also provides valuable insights into any training needs your recruitment team may have, ensuring you're well-prepared for the big switch. 

To approach this process, choose a small but representative sample of your recruitment processes and use this to test the new system. Make sure to include a variety of hiring scenarios and use cases. Document and monitor all interactions with the new tool, noting down any issues or glitches. Aside from technical aspects, consider user feedback. Collect their thoughts on the system's ease of use, efficiency, and overall experience. Lastly, we suggest working closely with your provider during this phase. Their expertise and guidance can be invaluable in troubleshooting issues and making the most out of the pilot testing phase. Remember, it's about ensuring a smooth transition, not merely switching systems.

4. Plan for efficient implementation

Embracing a future-forward recruitment strategy requires a measured, well-thought-out plan. Why, you ask? It's simple - to ensure a seamless shift, eliminating disruptions and maximizing the benefits that these modern tools offer. A detailed implementation plan, inclusive of data migration and system setup, minimizes potential snags that could stall your hiring process. It also guarantees that your team hits the ground running with the new system, fully prepared to leverage its strengths for your company’s benefit.

Begin with an in-depth analysis of your data migration needs. Which data points are critical to move? What format should they be in? Next, lay down the system setup procedures. How will your processes translate into the new system? Who will be the primary system users and administrators? Then, sketch a realistic timeline for the implementation. A well-defined timeline creates a clear vision of the steps ahead, reducing the risks of delays or missteps. Involve your recruitment team in these discussions. Their insights and hands-on experience will ensure a comprehensive plan that aligns perfectly with your organizational needs. 

5. Train your team

In adopting modern recruitment tools, training your team holds a pivotal role. Keep in mind that if your team members aren't adept at navigating the new system, the most sophisticated tool can become an expensive paperweight. Inadequate training could lead to underutilization of the system's capabilities, diminishing the expected return on your investment. Besides, proper training eases the transition for your team, fostering confidence and positivity about the change.

The first step to ensuring effective training is identifying team members who can quickly grasp new technology and train them thoroughly. As everyone learns differently, we suggest leveraging a mix of training formats such as interactive workshops, webinars, or video tutorials. Consider collaborating with your vendor for support as they can offer valuable tips and training resources. Above all, encourage an atmosphere of open dialogue and patience. Remember, it's normal for the team to take time to adapt and perfect the usage of new tools. So, ensure you cultivate a nurturing and understanding environment that fosters learning and adaptation at its own pace.

6. Monitor and evaluate the new system’s performance

In the dynamic recruitment landscape, deploying modern tools is not the end of the process. It's essential to guarantee that these new tools are delivering desired results for your team. This involves regularly assessing the performance of your new system, which goes beyond simply ticking off a task on your to-do list. The purpose is to ensure that the system is effectively helping you find and secure top candidates. This stage is critical to maximize the benefits of your new system and fine-tune it for even better service.

First, identify the Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that align with your recruitment goals. These could include factors like time-to-hire, quality of hire, or candidate experience. Then, don't let this be a once-in-a-blue-moon exercise. Make it a routine. Consistently check these metrics, making use of your new system's analytics capabilities. This process will enable you to quickly identify any issues and transform potential obstacles into opportunities. Moreover, ensure to consider the feedback of those who directly interact with the system - your hiring team and candidates. Their experiences can provide essential insights, helping your new tool become a truly effective part of your recruitment process.


The journey from legacy ATS to a world of modern recruitment tools can be rewarding and transformational. It's about infusing agility, flexibility, and data-driven insights into your hiring process. So, as you gaze into the horizon of the recruitment landscape, remember that evolving isn't a choice, but a necessity in these changing times. 

Aiding in this transition, Jobylon stands ready to elevate your talent acquisition to unparalleled heights. So why wait? Take a step towards a smarter, more effective recruitment process. Don't hesitate to book a demo with us and start exploring the transformative power of Jobylon today. With the right tools, the future of recruitment is yours to shape.

Last updated:

Sofia Lindman

I'm Sofia! A peanut butter brownie lover, +4 years traveling digital nomad, and the Content & Brand Marketing manager at Jobylon. With an underlying passion to elevate from the industrial age thinking, I love to inspire companies to create a modern, more autonomous workspace that resonates with the future workforce and create a new narrivate around what it means to work.

Get the latest updates

Subscribe to the blog to stay updated with the latest content on HR, recruiting, and the future of work


Want to see Jobylon in action?

Get a product tour of our talent acquisition platform and discover why we are loved by recruiters, hiring managers, and HR leaders across the world's largest employers!

Book a demo